Paradoxical Communication and Emotional Relationships: He Said “yes”, He Meant “no” and it All Ended

PsychologyFor Editorial Team Reviewed by PsychologyFor Editorial Team Editorial Review Reviewed by PsychologyFor Team Editorial Review

Paradoxical communication and emotional relationships he said yes he meant

Add Psychology For on Google

See more of our articles in your search results.

One of the mysteries of human communication is how we come to forget

At first glance, the structure of language allows us to understand each other clearly and precisely. However, you don’t always say what you mean, and there are times when the call is given. paradoxical communication

Paradoxical communication and the incongruent message

The Watzlawick team and their study with schizophrenic patients found the logic of misunderstanding. They differentiated two communicative levels: the digital level and the analog level The digital level refers to “what is said” and the content of the message, while the analog level refers to “what is meant” or the background intention. Therefore, not only the content of the message matters, but the intention behind it.

Generally, this would not be a problem, since people like consistency, so if a child says “I want ice cream,” we easily understand what to buy him. This fact is explained in that Words do not have a double meaning in themselves, but we are the ones who produce it Therefore, in the same way that both levels can coincide, they can also contradict each other. Sometimes, there are situations in which we ask for a change in the relationship with the interlocutor and we try an approach-avoidance with our communication.

Some examples

Let’s take the case of a girl who insists on going out at night, to which her mother responds “you yourself, you’ll see.” In this message the mother’s will is completely hidden; She does not inform him of her intention and her daughter must infer that she does not want him to go This is how your authority in the relationship is tested and the indecision arises between giving in to the intention or sticking to the content; between staying or leaving. What her daughter does implies a change in the relationship with her mother, a modification towards approach or avoidance.

This effect is called paradoxical communication and regardless of the option chosen, it does not have a happy ending. In the previous case, if the daughter decides not to go, she will feel discomfort because she has been told to do whatever she wants and she did not want to stay. But she, too, would not feel good if she had left, since it was not clear that her mother would be okay with her being hers. Neither option is a confirmation of what should be done, so whatever is done, there will always be the feeling of not doing the right thing Those are the two characteristic repercussions of paradox: confusion and discomfort.

Example of congruent communication

-Do you want something, son?

-I want ice cream.

-Okay, I’ll buy you an ice cream on the way home.

–digital level (content): wants an ice cream.

–Analog level (intention): wants an ice cream.

Example of incongruent communication: paradox

-Let me go out for a while tonight, come on…

-You yourself, Andrea, you will see…

    Snowball effect in communication

    Carmen (message): Juan, I’m terrible and the boy has made the room look lost.

    Juan: What do you want now? I’ve been working all day and it comes to me that the living room is dirty? You don’t want me to order it, do you? Having me clean the living room at 10 at night is annoying…

    Juan (upon arrival): Carmen, then you clean the living room!

    An obstacle in relationships

    The paradox is precisely one of the reasons why When problems arise in a couple, a lack of communication is referred to It is a symptom that reflects that the two members are not informing their intentions clearly enough when talking to the other.

    Likewise, it is also the initial point that paves the way for ruptures, since paradoxical communication is not a specific event, but rather drags on in conversations.

    Example 1 of paradoxical communication in courtship

    -Hey, are you doing something on Friday?

    -Yes, I’m going with Carlos and Fran for a walk.

    -Ah okay…

    -Did you want something?

    -No.

    -What will you do?

    -I’ll go to the movies with Juan.

    -OK, very good.

    -Well, very good. Don’t be angry, huh?

    -No, no, if I don’t get angry.

    -Well, that’s it, goodbye.

    -But hey…

    -Tell me.

    -Are you angry?

    -By? All good.

    -If you want, I’ll tell them to leave it for another day.

    -No, leave it.

    -Safe?

    -I had.

    -Well okay, don’t say anything later.

    -Ah… Okay, huh. Come on, goodbye.

    Example 2 of paradoxical communication in courtship

    -Tomorrow in the end I can’t stay.

    -Oops, oops… Well, I’m getting angry! And a lot! hahaha

    -Don’t be angry… We’re not there anymore, huh, pretty?

    -Be careful, maybe the one who doesn’t want to stay anymore is me…

    -Well then we won’t meet, there is no problem.

    -There is none, none.

    -There you.

    Beyond what is pronounced is what is said

    The paradox is characterized by the ambiguity, doubt in the other person’s intentions. It leaves a void in the dialogue between people that will grow and advance parallel to the communication in a snowball process. As long as we don’t understand something, we look for an explanation, and That explanation may be incorrect and we build part of our relationship with the person on it Faced with a message like “I feel terrible and the living room is dirty” it may well be understood as an intention of consolation or a request for cleanliness, to which our response would be very different.

    But if paradoxical communication can explain why couples end, it also explains why they do not form. Normally, being in a relationship you know the other person and can draw on mutually shared knowledge to fill the gap of paradox. That is how Knowing how the other usually relates, you can understand what intention they have However, that does not happen in the first approaches. When you start getting to know someone, the person is in the middle of a learning process; learning how the other relates and how it fits with one’s own way of relating.

    The role of expectations

    Added to this fact are other typical characteristics of the first approaches that foster paradoxes. One of them are The expectations, if it will be that special person with whom to share your own path. The anticipation of the results implies changes in the current way of communicating with the other, as well as it can cause both people to have different intentions. Now, if it seems that by communicating your intentions there should be no problems, fear and frustration appear to put a stone in the way.

    Saying what is expected of the other person means facing the fact that it may not coincide with other people’s expectations. Fear and frustration at the possibility that the other person does not want the same thing as us encourages us to keep our intentions secret Furthermore, a final factor is vulnerability, since making intentions explicit is revealing said secret and thus making us feel vulnerable.

    In this way, expectations, fear, frustration and the feeling of vulnerability lead to the appearance of paradoxes. These factors come together in courtship, where tension remains in a duality of approach-avoidance. That is, in “fooling” the other person’s intentions are constantly tested to check if they agree with one’s own. As we communicate, we reveal our desires and test those of the other, thus playing the well-known game of approaching and avoiding each other.

    Learn to deal with communication paradoxes

    Due to what has been said above, in the first steps in the formation of a couple, one’s intentions are hidden to a greater degree, favoring the appearance of paradoxes. Considering that there is still no knowledge of the other, the presence of paradoxes can be part of learning the interactional pattern

    This is how we can come to understand paradox as characteristic of the way of relating to others, becoming a common feature when communicating with them. If we still don’t know anything about the other person, we can come to the conclusion that this way of communicating is characteristic of our type of relationship. Operating from paradoxes implies a consecutive sequence of requests that are both about approaching and avoiding the other and for which, regardless of whether it is done, we will not feel good, since we do not know if the other option was better.

    This is how a small game creates a paradox that hinders communication and makes us both start walking without knowing where we are going or which path to choose.

      Use this citation format to reference the article clearly and help readers find the original source.

      Recommended citation Updated 2024

      PsychologyFor. (2024). Paradoxical Communication and Emotional Relationships: He Said “yes”, He Meant “no” and it All Ended. PsychologyFor. https://psychologyfor.com/paradoxical-communication-and-emotional-relationships-he-said-yes-he-meant-no-and-it-all-ended/

      Quick format for articles, references, and academic mentions.

      • This article has been reviewed by our editorial team at PsychologyFor to ensure accuracy, clarity, and adherence to evidence-based research. The content is for educational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional mental health advice. In case of a mental health crisis or emergency, call your local emergency services or contact a licensed professional immediately.